1In what ways do Ash Abumaraq's interpretations of religious texts challenge traditional views, and how does Mohamed Kilany respond to these interpretations in the context of contemporary issues faced by believers?
2How do the philosophical arguments presented by Ash Abumaraq regarding the nature of faith compare to Mohamed Kilany's stance on the relationship between religion and reason?
3Considering the historical context of their beliefs, how do Ash Abumaraq's and Mohamed Kilany's perspectives on religious authority differ, and what implications do these differences have for modern followers of their respective viewpoints?

How it works

Watch live

Both debaters answer each question in turn, then rebut each other.

Vote

After every round the audience votes — and picks the overall winner.

Chat

Talk with everyone in the arena while it happens.

Ask

Submit your own questions for the debaters.

ash vs kilany